Map ratings

[Zaiross]

Everybody who pass map can rate. It can being realised with simple command. On map list in vote menu will being showed how good is map (one IP - max one rate per map)

[hi_leute_gll]

Often suggested, often declined.

[BannZay]

1 nickname - 1 vote.
minimum pts = 200 for example

[hi_leute_gll]

W/o an acc.-system this is very easily to fake, also in a rather small community the mappers with the most friends will get the most votes.

[BannZay]

oh, really. Then its impossible to make good map rating indicator on this stage of ddnet system... =(

[Zaiross]

I mean IP, thanks BannZay

[Ryozuki]

I mean IP, thanks BannZay

proxy...

[Frrrrr :3]

W/o an acc.-system this is very easily to fake, also in a rather small community the mappers with the most friends will get the most votes.

Not true. Naufrage series will take all benefits.
And aMa maps will take 1 vote by aMa.

By the way, player rating is most needed thing for the ddnet.
Without challenge between mappers 95% of maps will be bullshit, like it's happening right now.

I think best solution - voting possible only 1 min after finish. And, and! Votes must be hidden. Only sum of result are showing. Wanna rate? Finish map. Simple as fingers.

And ofcourse this system is not about rating mappers, its about rating maps!

[Welf]

It wont work like that, others already told you the reasons^^

One possibility would be to make a jury to rate maps, that might be fair (but we don't have time to rate 1k maps )

If you want feedback for your maps, ask some experienced players. I also can give feedback if you want (i often rate maps in map testing section).
Search for friends who like to work on your maps, to improve the quality

[Soreu]

Often suggested, often declined.

It wont work like that, others already told you the reasons

1. [suggestion] like, don't like map button
2. like maps

I'm sure there were at least 2 more topics, but I'm not going to search carefully for them...